Baldwin Pizza

Baldwin Pizza in Baldwin, NY offers authentic NY-style pizza, Sicilian pies, garlic knots, and vegetarian options. Enjoy quick delivery, takeout, or dine-in with family-friendly ambiance, wheelchair accessible parking, and great prices. Perfect for lunch or dinner—visit us today!

MenuContact

Welcome to Baldwin Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Baldwin Pizza
Baldwin Pizza
Baldwin Pizza
Baldwin Pizza

Nestled in the heart of Baldwin, NY at 1841 Grand Ave, Baldwin Pizza offers a slice of classic New York style pizza combined with community charm. We serve as a neighborhood hub where families, friends, and solo diners gather for delicious comfort food and quick bites. Our menu features a variety of options, from traditional pies to vegetarian selections, all crafted with high-quality ingredients. We’re known for our perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio, crispy crust, and generous toppings that satisfy every craving. Whether you’re stopping by for lunch, dinner, or a late-night snack, Baldwin Pizza welcomes you with a warm atmosphere and friendly service.

Our commitment to affordability and accessibility means everyone in the neighborhood can enjoy a slice of authentic New York flavor. Join us, and become part of our local food family—because good pizza is more than just a meal, it’s a community staple.

Location & Contact

Address

1841 Grand Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510, United States

Phone

+1 516-223-6700

About

Baldwin Pizza
Baldwin Pizza
Baldwin Pizza
Baldwin Pizza

Since opening, Baldwin Pizza has become a local staple known for its authentic New York style pizza and inviting community atmosphere. We source fresh, high-quality ingredients for all our offerings—be it our signature pies, crispy wings, or fresh salads. Our team focuses on delivering consistent, top-tier taste with every order, whether you’re dining in or ordering for delivery. The restaurant’s lively vibe reflects the neighborhood’s friendly spirit, making it a perfect spot for families, students, and workers to unwind. Over the years, we’ve built a reputation based on affordability, cleanliness, and a welcoming environment.

Our menu caters to diverse tastes, from traditional favorites like Sicilian pizza and baked ziti to vegetarian and gluten-free options. Baldwin Pizza is not just about food; it’s about community connection—sharing good times over great slices that keep customers coming back. We uphold standards of excellence while celebrating the local flavor of Baldwin, NY.

Work Hours

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

Baldwin Pizza stands out with its quick service options including delivery, takeaway, and cozy dine-in seating. We cater to diverse needs, offering vegetarian options and kid-friendly meals, including high chairs. Our casual, family-friendly vibe encourages relaxed dining, whether you’re alone at lunch or celebrating a family night. Free street parking, on-site parking, and a wheelchair-accessible car park ensure easy access for all. Our menu covers everything from classic slices, garlic knots, and fresh salads to hearty pastas, entrees, and even Mexican favorites.

Peak times see Saturday afternoons at full capacity, but early weekdays remain peaceful for a quick, satisfying visit. Baldwin Pizza prides itself on quality ingredients, consistent flavor, and a welcoming atmosphere—your go-to spot for reliable, delicious comfort food.

Baldwin Pizza

Baldwin Pizza boasts a welcoming facade on Grand Ave, with a vibrant sign inviting locals inside. The outdoor setup features a comfortable seating area where families and friends gather, especially during pleasant weather. The casual vibe extends through bright, friendly decor and an energetic atmosphere that captures the neighborhood’s lively spirit. Walking past, you can smell the aroma of freshly baked pizza and garlic knots, tempting passersby.

The parking lot and street parking are easily accessible, ensuring hassle-free visits. Inside, the vibe is lively yet relaxed, perfect for quick bites or prolonged family dinners. Whether you’re sitting at the counter or taking out to enjoy at home, Baldwin Pizza’s exterior and ambiance reflect its community roots—authentic, approachable, and dedicated to making every visit enjoyable.

Customer Reviews

The Pizza In Rockville Centre is forgettable except for Front Street Pizza. Baldwin Pizza makes an old school NY Style Pizza. Their Sicilian Pie is awesome too. Great quality ingredients. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese.

A
Albert N.

Great service, Great Price, Delicious! I ordered everything pizza.Its absolutely best quality and best value for your money well spend. Super friendly.Highly recommended!

P
Pop C.

Not enough stars to tell how great the experience was. All food was fresh. My brothers eat there twice a week and they say the food is ALWAYS GOOD, They have not been disappointed ever in years. The owner said they are his best customers. He was welcoming, grateful and joyful. I cannot eat cheese or bread, so I was a little skeptical, but they made exactly what I asked for and were happy to cater to my request for no raw onions and no cheese. Delicious. Also provided little cup of mayo and one of tomato sauce at my request. I was satisfied. Salad was fresh and so was sautéed spinach. The spinach was not on the menu, so was made fresh just for me, enough to bring half home. Thank you, Baldwin Pizza, for helping me celebrate my 70th birthday with my family. I shall return!

L
Louise S.

I purchased a pizza pie 5/17/24. And it was horrible. I have been coming here for a couple months because I find it through a co worker and the pizza was amazing. I don't know who prepared the pie this Friday but it was low quality in taste and appearance. It was dry and had a very thin layer of cheese. I paid 15.00 for this pie. What a waste. If I didn't live so far I would have brought it back. I was very disappointed because they are usually on point. Makes me leary of purchasing anything else from them again. But I will give them another try. Maybe it was a different cook, or they were low on food supplies, not sure but I hope this isn't the norm. Very disappointed 😞 What a waste of money.

K
Katrina F.

Delicious pizza and very excellent service.

S
Shervon M.

The pizza is great, just the right crispness and not doughy. The sauce has a nice flavor. The garlic knots were also very good

S
Sean K.